Grand Illusion: The Myth of Voter Choice in a Two-Party Tyranny
As the national campaign manager for Ralph Nader's historic runs for president in 2000 and 2004, Theresa Amato had a rare ringside role in two of the most hotly contested presidential elections this country has seen. In Grand Illusion, she gives us a witty, thoughtful critique of the American electoral system, as well as a powerful argument for opening up the contest to competition. Busting the national myth that "anyone can grow up and be President of the United States," Amato shows how independent and third-party candidates face egregious structural barriers that prevent them from fully participating in the race or even getting their names on the ballot. In addition to waging effective voter campaigns, these candidates must simultaneously fend off preposterous numbers of legal challenges from the two major parties - during twelve weeks of Nader's 2004 run, as many as twenty-five lawsuits were filed in an effort to squash his campaign. Amato makes a powerful case for specific federal reforms in the United States' arcane state system of ballot access laws, complex regulations, and partisan control of elections. Along the way, she also offers a spirited history of how third-part and independent candidates have kept important issues on the table in elections past and contribute to our political life. Despite the dramatic run-up to the historic 2008 election and the efforts of both Obama and McCain to set themselves apart, the national political debate occurs in a very narrow range that's defined by two major parties, which are both influenced by the same corporations, special interest groups, and lobbyists. And on Election day, there just are not the kinds of genuine options that a healthy, multi-party democracy should offer. Looking beyond the Nader story to campaigns waged by challengers John Anderson, Ross Perot, Pat Buchanan, and others, Amato shows how limiting ourselves to two major parties deprives our country of a robust political life, strips would-be contenders of their First Amendment rights, and cheats voters out of meaningful political choice.
The work available here is the abstract. Locate the full-text of the article using the DOI below.
Amato, Theresa A. J.D., "Grand Illusion: The Myth of Voter Choice in a Two-Party Tyranny" (2009). Justice Studies Faculty Publications. 3.